I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (2024)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (1)

I’ve been stoked to fully test the MSI Claw since I tried it at CES 2024.

While I like other Windows 11 handhelds like the Asus ROG Ally and Lenovo Legion Go, Microsoft’s operating system and the machines’ respective launchers don’t work as seamlessly as SteamOS does on the Steam Deck. The Meteor Lake-driven MSI Claw gave me hope for Windows 11 handhelds, but unfortunately, the reality isn't living up to the hype.

I’ve just received an MSI Claw review unit and have begun putting it through its paces. While there are aspects I love, such as how good it feels to hold, how quietly it runs and its vivid 1080p 120Hz display, I’ve been disappointed by the overall experience. The main culprit? You guessed it — the software.

Though software updates may eventually mitigate the issues I’m having, that won’t help anyone who spends upwards of $799 at launch for this handheld. I’m a tech reviewer so I have patience when dealing with finicky devices… but that’s not true for the average person who just wants a gaming handheld to play the best PC games.

I’ll have a full review of the MSI Claw for you soon. For now, here are my initial thoughts — and why you might want to hold off on buying this device for now.

Troublesome software

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (2)

When I first began testing the ROG Ally and Legion Go, I went through the same setup process as on the best Windows laptops and best computers. I didn’t care to do that on a gaming handheld, but given these are Windows 11 machines, this process was unavoidable.

I went through the same process when setting up the MSI Claw. However, there was the added bonus of also ensuring all the latest Intel graphics updates were installed. I didn’t know about the latter initially, which was frustrating given the number of crashes I dealt with after setting up Windows 11. Installing two of the three available Intel drivers went fine, but at time of writing, I haven’t been able to download the Intel Arc and Iris Xe Graphics updates — which might mitigate some of the instability I'm experiencing.

Simply launching a game shouldn’t be this difficult on a gaming device.

I have mixed feelings about MSI Center, which serves as the Claw’s launcher. Though I appreciate its clean and simple interface, it doesn’t work as I expected. For instance, if I select a Steam game, the Steam launcher will sometimes pop up — forcing me to use touchscreen controls to select a game. In other instances, selecting a game from MSI Center instantly launches it... which is what's supposed to happen. The inconsistency is frustrating. Quitting a game also returns you to the desktop instead of back to MSI Center, which isn’t great.

Software updates can iron out most of the problems I’ve outlined. MSI Center and Intel’s graphics drivers will likely receive patches but Windows 11 is still a concern — though Xbox’s Phil Spencer promises Microsoft is working to make the operating system work better for handhelds. But as I said above, if you’re paying up to $799 for an MSI Claw (the entry-level model is $699), then you deserve a more seamless experience. Simply launching a game shouldn’t be this difficult on a gaming device.

But there’s hope

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (3)

I don’t want to completely dismiss the MSI Claw. In the Claw’s performance mode, I was able to play Doom Eternal at 30 to 40 frames per second (fps) at 1080p resolution and medium graphical settings. At 720p, the game runs at a little over 60 fps. Cyberpunk 2077, which can utilize Intel XeSS (Intel’s answer to Nvidia DLSS and AMD FreeSync), runs at a relatively stable 30 fps thanks to the frame-boosting technology.

These results are about on par with other Windows 11 handhelds at 1080p and better than Steam Deck at 720p. So when I’m actually able to successfully launch games, performance holds up well.

I might change my mind after I’ve spent more time with the MSI Claw. Again, I love the ergonomic design and how quietly it runs. But if its issues aren’t addressed soon, it might end up being the worst Windows 11 handheld from a major manufacturer. That’d be surprising given how the company makes some of the best gaming laptops and best gaming PCs we’ve tested.

As things stand, I can’t recommend the MSI Claw. Not until the company fixes the existing issues I and other reviewers have experienced. But again, I'll make a final determination in my full MSI Claw review.

More from Tom's Guide

  • Steam Deck OLED vs Steam Deck LCD: Biggest differences
  • I’ve used the Asus ROG Ally for 2 months — here’s what I think now
  • The best handheld gaming consoles in 2024

Category

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (4)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (5)

Back to Game Consoles

Brand

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (6)

Storage Size

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (7)

Colour

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (8)

Showing 10 of 54 deals

Filters

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (10)

(512GB White)

Our Review

1

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (11)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (12)

(512GB White)

Our Review

2

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (13)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (14)

Lenovo Legion Go

Our Review

3

$699.99

View Deal

Low Stock

(512GB 16GB RAM)

Our Review

4

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (17)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (18)

Lenovo Legion Go

(512GB AMD Ryzen)

Our Review

5

$699.99

View Deal

(Black)

Our Review

6

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (21)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (22)

(512GB 16GB RAM)

Our Review

8

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (25)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (26)

(16GB RAM AMD Ryzen)

Our Review

10

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (29)

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (30)

Load more deals

Sign up to get the BEST of Tom's Guide direct to your inbox.

Here at Tom’s Guide our expert editors are committed to bringing you the best news, reviews and guides to help you stay informed and ahead of the curve!

I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (31)

Tony Polanco

Computing Writer

Tony is a computing writer at Tom’s Guide covering laptops, tablets, Windows, and iOS. During his off-hours, Tony enjoys reading comic books, playing video games, reading speculative fiction novels, and spending too much time on X/Twitter. His non-nerdy pursuits involve attending Hard Rock/Heavy Metal concerts and going to NYC bars with friends and colleagues. His work has appeared in publications such as Laptop Mag, PC Mag, and various independent gaming sites.

More about handheld gaming

8BitDo Ultimate Mobile Gaming Controller brings the Hall Effect to Android gamingValve discusses plans for new Steam Deck models and it's good news for consumers

Latest

Epic Amazon weekend sale is live — 21 deals I'd shop ahead of Black Friday from $6
See more latest►

No comments yetComment from the forums

    Most Popular
    ‘Terrifier’ is the biggest movie in horror right now — and that worries me
    I’ve been using the Moonbird breathing coach device to build mental strength — here’s my verdict
    Forget iPhone 17 Pro Max — Snapdragon 8 Elite could beat Apple with the one feature I've been waiting for
    I’m a stomach sleeper, here’s why I’m super fussy about my pillows
    iPhone SE 4 Plus could be the big-screen phone of 2025 — here's why
    Netflix's new No.1 movie transforms true crime — and I can't stop thinking about it
    I thought double-sided mattresses were a gimmick until I tried one — here's what happened
    Apple reportedly '2 years behind' on AI with Apple Intelligence — here's why
    Here's why "Rocky Horror Picture Show" remains an important movie
    Antidepressants used to help me sleep, now I rely on these 3 things instead
    After Metaphor: ReFantazio, I'm not sure I can go back to Persona
    I wanted to like the MSI Claw — and then I tested it (2024)

    References

    Top Articles
    Latest Posts
    Recommended Articles
    Article information

    Author: Laurine Ryan

    Last Updated:

    Views: 5782

    Rating: 4.7 / 5 (77 voted)

    Reviews: 92% of readers found this page helpful

    Author information

    Name: Laurine Ryan

    Birthday: 1994-12-23

    Address: Suite 751 871 Lissette Throughway, West Kittie, NH 41603

    Phone: +2366831109631

    Job: Sales Producer

    Hobby: Creative writing, Motor sports, Do it yourself, Skateboarding, Coffee roasting, Calligraphy, Stand-up comedy

    Introduction: My name is Laurine Ryan, I am a adorable, fair, graceful, spotless, gorgeous, homely, cooperative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.